Anima Mundi: The Rise of the World Soul Theory in Modern German Philosophy, 2011
International Archives of the History of Ideas Archives internationales d'histoire des idées Series, Vol. 202

This work presents and philosophically analyzes the early modern and modern history of the theory concerning the soul of the world, anima mundi. The initial question of the investigation is why there was a revival of this theory in the time of the early German Romanticism, whereas the concept of the anima mundi had been rejected in the earlier, classical period of European philosophy (early and mature Enlightenment). The presentation and analysis starts from the Leibnizian-Wolffian school, generally hostile to the theory, and covers classical eighteenth-century physico-theology, also reluctant to accept an anima mundi. Next, it discusses early modern and modern Christian philosophical Cabbala (Böhme and Ötinger), an intellectual tradition which to some extent tolerated the idea of a soul of the world. The philosophical relationship between Spinoza and Spinozism on the one hand, and the anima mundi theory on the other is also examined. An analysis of Giordano Bruno?s utilization of the concept anima del mondo is the last step before we give an account of how and why German Romanticism, especially Baader and Schelling asserted and applied the theory of the Weltseele. The purpose of the work is to prove that the philosophical insufficiency of a concept of God as an ens extramundanum instigated the Romantics to think an anima mundi that can act as a divine and quasi-infinite intermediary between God and Nature, as a locum tenens of God in physical reality.

I: Opposition to the identification of the World Soul with God in the philosophia Leibnitio-Wolffiana : The theory of God as the "ens extramundanum." 1. Presentation of the texts relevant for the concept of an "anima mundi." The immediate natural theological setting of the problem. 2. The distinctive philosophical content of the concept of an "anima mundi" in Leibniz and his followers. Arguments of this school against the theory of anima mundi. A broader natural philosophical and metaphysical discussion of their answer positions. II: "Les naturalistes" – XVIIIth-century physico-theology : The scientific demonstration of the existence and attributes of God from the teleology of nature. The World Soul theory in physico-theology. Physico-theology as a source of inspiration for the Romantics. 1. Preliminary historical and conceptual presentation of "l’histoire naturelle" in selected major works of some leading naturalists. The relation of natural science to theology or spirituality in their works. 2. General philosophical analysis of physico-theology. III. Gradual rise of the concept of a World Soul in the ‘Lessingszeit’. Philosophical Cabbala, Spinozism and mysticism : Böhme & Ötinger; Spinoza, Lessing, & the Pantheismus-Streit; Giordano Bruno’s influence in the epoch. 1. Böhme’s speculative theology (De signatura rerum, 1622). Ötinger’s Cabbalistic theory of the world as a glorious divine epiphany or shekhina & his problematic rejection of the concept of Weltseele (Offentliches Denckmahl der Lehr-tafel einer … Prinzessin Antonia, 1763). 2. The philosophical incompatibility of Spinoza’s system with the World Soul theory. Bayle’s identification of Spinozism with the World Soul theory, and Wachter’s denial of the same. Lessing’s statement concerning the World Soul, and his alleged Spinozism in Jacobi’s Ueber die Lehre des Spinoza… (1785), Mendelssohn’s Morgenstunden… (1785), and Herder’s Gott. Einige Gespräche (1787). Herder’s rejection of the identification of God with the Weltseele. 3. The World Soul in Giordano Bruno’s De la causa, principio et uno (1584) and De l’infinito, universo e mondi (1584). The revival of Bruno’s philosophy in late XVIIIth-early XIXth century German thought. IV. The philosophical postulation of the World Soul in German Romanticism. Baader and Schelling.

Important monograph on the (early) modern theory of the Soul of the World

Examines the World Soul problematique in a broad metaphysical context

Includes interdisciplinary discussion between metaphysics, theology, natural philosophy

Covers non-mainstream intellectual traditions such as Cabbala, Hermetism

Includes unpublished early modern manuscript material