Schelling versus Hegel
From German Idealism to Christian Metaphysics

In tracing Friedrich von Schelling's long philosophical development, John Laughland examines in particular his disentanglement from German idealism and his reaction, later in life, against Hegel. He argues that this story has relevance beyond the facts themselves and that it explains much about the direction philosophy took in the century between the French Revolution and the rise of Communism. Schelling's development turned principally on the related questions of human liberty and the creation. Following a sharp disagreement with his old friend Hegel over the Phenomenology in 1807, Schelling wrote a short but brilliant essay on human freedom in 1809, after which he never published another word. In the remaining decades of his life (d. 1854) Schelling developed in an increasingly conservative and Christian direction, preoccupied with the relationship between Christianity and metaphysics. In numerous lectures and unpublished works, he attacked what he saw as the hubris and artificiality of Hegelian rationalism. However the path against which Schelling warned was the one which philosophy finally took. Schelling was determined to show how philosophy (especially ontology) explained and was explained by Christianity, and that both had been damaged by modern rationalism. But Hegel?s Marxist epigones who attended his later lectures scoffed and Hegelianism triumphed. This is an elegantly written and engaging study in the history of ideas of a philosopher on the losing side.

Chapter 1 The Creation, Liberty and Evil, John Laughland; Chapter 2 The Question of Being, John Laughland; Chapter 3 Schelling's Beginnings, John Laughland; Chapter 4 The Metaphysics of Evil, John Laughland; Chapter 5 Christian Cosmogony and the End of Idealism (Schelling's Development from Stuttgart to Munich, 1810–27), John Laughland; Chapter 6 The Religious Flowering in Schelling's Late Philosophy, John Laughland;

John Laughland has been a lecturer in philosophy and politics at the Institute of Political Studies in Paris, at the Sorbonne Nouvelle (Paris III), at the University of St. Pius V in Rome and at the University of Bucharest. He is the author of 'The Death of Politics: France under Mitterrand' (1994); 'The Tainted Source: the Undemocratic Origins of the European Idea' (1997) , 'Le tribunal penal international: gardien du nouvel ordre mondial (Paris, 2003) and 'Travesty: the Trial of Slobodan Milosevic and the Corruption of International Justics (2007). He is the editor of the current affairs quarterly, 'Geopolitical Affairs'.